EDM Technical Manual

CHAPTER 8: JOB FACTORS

Each application will have its own parameters that will influence the electrode material selected. Job parameters such as workmetal, cavity size, shape, and surface finish are all important, but achieving the desired results efficiently will depend on a good electrode to workmetal match.

WORKMETAL

The EDM process is not affected by the hardness of the workmetal. The thermal properties of the metal determine its machinability by EDM. That is why the melting temperature of the workpiece metal plays an important part in how different grades of graphite perform. The following chart shows typical melting points for some common workmetals. Notice that tungsten carbide, one of the most difficult workmetals to cut, has a very high melting point.

Common Work Metals
TYPE °F Melting Point °C Melting Point
Tool Steel (06) 2,732 1,500
Stainless Steel (410) 2,700-2,790 1,482-1,532
Titanium (Ti-6AL-4V) 3,000 1,649
Inconel (718) 2,300-2,437 1,260-1,336
Tungsten Carbide (K-68) 6,054 3,360
Aluminum (6061-T6) 1,080-1,200 582-649

Workpiece Properties

Tool Steel —Applications for this material include blanking dies and punches, master gauges, hobs for non-ferrous metals, drawing and forming dies, flanging dies, drill bushings, thread gauges, taps and reamers for non-ferrous metals.

Typical Analysis
Carbon 1.45%
Manganese 0.65%
Silicon 1.00%
Molybdenum 0.25%
Iron Balance

 

Stainless Steel — In the aircraft industry, it is used for parts such as compressor shrouds where oxidation resistance is required.

Typical Analysis
Carbon 0.15% max.
Manganese 1.00% max.
Silicon 1.00% max.
Chromium 11.5-13.5%
Phosphorus 0.040% max.
Iron Balance

 

Titanium Alloy— This versatile alloy is used in aircraft and jet engine parts, pressure vessels, rocket motor cases, marine parts and chemical processing equipment.

Typical Analysis
Titanium 90%
Aluminum 6%
Vanadium 4%

Inconel — For high temperature applications requiring excellent corrosion resistance and strength. Used in jet engines and extrusion dies.

Typical Analysis
Carbon 0.08%
Manganese 0.35%
Nickel 50-55%
Chromium 17-21%
Columbium and Tantalum 4.75-5.5%
Molybdenum 2.8-3.3%
Cobalt 1.0%
Titanium 0.65-1.15%
Aluminum 0.2-0.8%
Silicon 0.35%
Copper 0.3%
Sulfur 0.015%
Phosphorus 0.015%
Boron 0.006%
Iron Balance

Tungsten Carbide — Excellent for metal forming dies and punches.

Typical Analysis
Cobalt 5.8%
Tungsten Carbide Balance

Aluminum— Ideal for prototype molds.

Typical Analysis
Manganese 0.8-1.2%
Silicon 0.4- 0.8%
Chromium 0.15-0.35%
Copper 0.15-0.40%
Aluminum Balance

Workmetal/Graphite Selection

The following chart is a good guide to selecting a classification of graphite materials for different workpiece metals. This chart can be used for general guidance in selecting a classification of material. Specific requirements of an application may require selection of an alternate material.

Guide to Graphite Electrode Material Selection
 
Graphite Classifications
Work Metals Angstrofine Ultrafine Superfine Fine Medium
Tool Steels F R,F R R  
Stainless Steels F R,F* R,F R,F  
Aluminum   F R,F R R
Titanium F R,F R    
Carbides   R*,F* R*,F*    
Precious Metals F R,F* R    
Copper   R*,F* R*,F*    


LEGEND: R, rougher and F, finisher
* Can also use copper infiltrated graphite

Workmetal/Electrode Polarity

The following chart is a guide for selecting the graphite electrode polarity to use with different workmetals. Some workmetals can be machined with electrodes in either polarity depending on the desired results (figure 8-1).

Guide to Electrode Polarity
Workmetal Rougher Finisher
Tool Steel +* ±
Stainless Steels +* ±
Aluminum ± ±
Titanium - -
Carbides - -
Copper - -

*Negative polarity can be used when maximum speed is the only requirement.

Figure 8-1. These two charts show the electrode wear and metal removal rate of two electrode materials. In the top chart, both electrode materials in positive polarity had the same metal removal rate and low wear. This would be ideal for a finishing operation. In the bottom chart, the electrodes are in negative polarity and the metal removal rate has doubled, but with increased wear. This would be ideal for a roughing situation where electrode wear is less important.

Specific information can be found in the performance data charts that were produced by POCO's Objective Comparison Testing Program. They offer the best method of predicting the metal removal rate, wear resistance, and final surface finish obtained for a given electrode material/workmetal combination. These charts allow immediate comparison of MRR, EW, and SF at a variety of duty cycles and currents.

Workmetal Notes

Tungsten Carbide — To prevent this material from cracking, 15 amps is the maximum average current that should be used.

Copper Alloys — Use negative polarity and expect low MRR and high electrode wear.

Aluminum — Although aluminum is easy to machine, it is hard to get a good surface finish.

ELECTRODE

Electrode Size

The block size of graphite is not a limiting factor when choosing a material. If the electrode requires a size larger than is currently available in the specific graphite grade needed, there are several techniques that can be used to fabricate a larger graphite electrode. Partial area or pieced electrodes can be fabricated by brazing, bonding, and/or simply mechanically attaching smaller graphite pieces to a backing plate, and can result in a very large electrode.

Electrode Shape

As the amount of detail to be reproduced increases so should the quality of the electrode material. Angstrofine and Ultrafine materials will reproduce more detail with less electrode wear than the materials in the other classifications.

Maximum Amperage Applied to the Electrode

The size and shape of the finished electrode is important in determining the maximum peak amperage (Ip) that can be applied to the electrode. A safe guideline is 50 amps per square inch. Excessive amperage can cause instability and DC arcing in the cut. Very small electrodes can be easily damaged by excessive amperage.

Before the maximum peak amperage can be calculated, the frontal area of the electrode minus the area of any flush holes must be determined. Then the following formula can be used:

Maximum Peak Amperage

The resulting peak current should be the maximum setting for that electrode. Large electrodes with protruding fine detail will have little of the electrode face starting the cut. The high amperage could damage the electrode before the cut becomes stabilized. Therefore the operator should seat the electrode at a lower peak current setting before increasing to maximum calculated peak current. This seating operation can be programmed into a CNC machine.

Electrode Position

Generally, the electrode is mounted on the ram head and the workpiece is mounted on the base, but the positions can be switched. It is important to remember that when discussing polarity it is always the polarity to the electrode, not the ram or the worktable.

One of the many reasons to switch the location of the electrode and the workpiece is to improve flushing. Electrode position often depends on the particular application. Multiple parts can be mounted on tooling and loaded into the tool changer to increase the length of unattended operation. There are many applications where changing the electrode and workpiece location will improve the performance of the job (figure 8-2).

Figure 8-2

Figure 8-2. Cutting a pattern into a roller is an ideal application for reversing the electrode and workpiece positions. Allot electrode can be mounted on the base to cut the roller as it is turned on the spindle. (Courtesy of OAR Tool & Die, inc.; Providence, R.1.)

Electrode Fabrication

There are a number of methods to fabricate electrodes. Traditional machining methods, wirecut EDM, abrading and ultrasonic methods are discussed in Chapter 10. The size and shape of the electrode along with the particular application are important considerations when choosing a fabrication method.

EDM EQUIPMENT

Generally, a cavity cut on a manual machine without orbiting will require more electrodes than the same cavity cut on a CNC machine.

Electrodes for unattended CNC EDM should be of the best material available for that particular job. The machine's ability to compensate for poor machining conditions caused by an inferior graphite will extend the machining time.

A tool changing CNC EDM is of little use if you are constantly having to clear the gap or redress and replace electrodes before they have finished a particular operation.